Voce del Popolo

In the current climate where #metoo and #blacklivesmatter seem to be heralding real change there are some interesting debates about historic artworks; either because they represent people or events that are now seen as offensive or because the behaviour of their creators has been equally unacceptable.  Consequently we have seen calls for Confederate statues to be removed or destroyed (watch out Mt Rushmore), a memorial to a conscientious objector taken down, complaints about paedophilia to the Met in NY, a Manchester gallery see-sawing over whether to display a painting of naked nymphs, a some sexually active buildings planned to neighbour the Louvre given a firm “non” in Paris.  Acclaimed work by Woody Allen and Kevin Spacey is now viewed very differently, but should we be able to separate the artist from their work; or see historic events as milestones in our journey to who and where we are?

Perhaps the greatest concern with this and so many debates today is that the clamour for change is stoked by social media where arguments snowball as a result of knee jerk outrage rather than any considered judgement.

One of the largest open spaces in Rome, is the Piazza del Popolo, and though it was originally named after the poplar trees around the area in modern Italian it means People’s Square, and now that it has been pedestrianised it would be the ideal place for public gatherings, or in the current climate would that run the risk of becoming a mob?  This was until the 19th century the site of public executions.  Italy has recently begun to suffer from populist politics too with racial attacks in a country that has long been more tolerant than many European neighbours.

Most people who visit the Piazza notice the twin churches that flank the opening of Via del Corso, the Rameses II obelisk and Egyptian styled fountains at the heart, and the steps that lead to the house and gardens of the Villa Borghese.  The city gateway at the north of the space, the Porta del Popolo is quite anonymous by comparison, but even this has more impact than the church that adjoins it.  I wonder what proportion of the popolo venture through the door?  They should.

There are a multitude of reasons to do so; a chapel designed by Raphael, a scattering of Bernini sculptures, and a macabre moment or two, but for this photographer there is one draw that will always overshadow the others.

The altar in the Cerasi Chapel features a work by Carracci, a promising painter of his day but it is rendered invisible by the pieces on either side by another up and comer; Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio.   Caravaggio’s realism and use of light and shade were surely precursors for every dramatic photograph.
His work here demonstrates another aspect of his character; both works proffer a backside to his rival.  This is relatively subtle in The Crucifixion of St Peter, and the saint’s legs and feet are the attention grabbers; old, dirty and anything but idealised.

Turn to the Conversion of St Paul and there’s no doubt that he’s showing the horse’s arse to his rival.  So Caravaggio was irrepressibly cheeky (excuse the pun), but his disregard for authority went much further.  Gambling, fighting, an illegitimate child and eventually murder featured on his charge sheet.

Time to take down and destroy the Caravaggio’s?  How do we then differ from the monument destroyers of ISIS?

 

 

Advertisements

The Light Pours Out of Me*

I recently went to see the Mike Leigh film Mr Turner, in which Timothy Spall gives a tour de force performance, despite much of his dialogue consisting of little more than grunts.

As a photographer I’ve always loved the way Caravaggio used light, illuminating small pockets of action in scenes of impenetrable darkness very much as studio lighting can be used to aid the camera.  Turner was a very different painter, though in his own way, just as inspirational to a humble snapper like me.  My favourite landscape photographs would be taken on wet and overcast days at Seaburn, when the water lying on the surface of the beach mirrored the skies above, and the rain blurred the edges of sea, sky and sand.  Turner’s paintings similarly blurred the edges of reality with sublime stormy skies.

As I left the cinema it was raining and the sky still had a gun-metal glow; the trouble was I was nowhere near anything worth photographing, and with the drive home ahead of me would need my hands for the steering wheel.  Time to experiment.

With a couple of pocket wizards I was able to set up a remote control for the shutter that I could activate with one thumb while still keeping both hands on the wheel.  With the heavy camera in a silicon shell, it stuck nicely on the dashboard and I was ready to see what the wet roads and cloudy skies had to offer.

I have to say it wasn’t a great success, but there were a couple of examples that I liked; one with an added texture vignette and the other pretty much as shot.

I won’t be applying to join the Royal Academy just yet!

untitled-72-Edit

untitled-74

*One of the songs played by a band I was in another lifetime ago.  Here’s a link to the original by Magazine…

Magazine – The Light Pours Out Of Me